Using a low-cost apparatus designed to quickly and accurately measure the properties of handheld laser devices, researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST, an agency of the US Department of Commerce) have tested 122 laser pointers and found that nearly 90% of green pointers and about 44% of red pointers were out of compliance with federal safety regulations. The NIST test apparatus was designed so that it can be replicated easily by other institutions.
As NIST reported on 20 March at the the International Laser Safety Conference in Orlando, FL, USA, both red and green laser pointers often emitted more visible power than allowed under the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), and green pointers often emitted unacceptable levels of infrared light as well (J. Hadler, E.L. Tobares and M. Dowell, ‘Random testing reveals excessive power in commercial laser pointers. Random testing reveals excessive power in commercial laser pointers’, Journal of Laser Applications, to be published).
Anecdotal reports of green laser hazards have previously appeared in scientific journals and the media, but the new NIST tests are claimed to be the first reported precision measurements of a large number of handheld laser devices. The NIST tests point out that many red laser pointers are also, unexpectedly, out of compliance with federal regulations. “Our results raise numerous safety questions regarding laser pointers and their use,” say the researchers.
The tests were conducted on randomly selected commercial laser devices labeled as Class IIIa or 3R and sold as suitable for demonstration use in classrooms and other public spaces. Such lasers are limited under the CFR to 5mW maximum emission in the visible portion of the spectrum and less than 2mW in the infrared portion of the spectrum. About half the devices tested emitted power levels at least twice the CFR limit at one or more wavelengths. The highest measured power output was 66.5mW, more than 10 times the legal limit. The power measurements were accurate to within 5%.
According to the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), laser devices that exceed 3R limits may be hazardous and should be subject to more rigorous controls, such as training, to prevent injury (American National Standard for the Safe Use of Lasers (ANSI Z136-2007) Section 1.2 and Table 1. Lasers that exceed 3R emissions limits are classified as 3B or 4).
NIST is a non-regulatory agency with decades of experience providing industry, research and military agencies with laser power measurements traceable to international standards. It also has a history of innovation in devices for making such measurements. Technical staff from NIST's Laser Radiometry Project built the laser pointer test bed and collaborated with the NIST Office of Safety, Health and Environment on the tests. NIST has provided its data on laser pointer power measurements to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which regulates laser product safety.
Green lasers generate green light from infrared light. Ideally, the device should be designed and manufactured to confine the infrared light within the laser housing. However, according to the new NIST results, more than 75% of the devices tested emitted infrared light in excess of the CFR limit.
Picture: NIST laser safety officer Joshua Hadler and his apparatus for measuring the properties of handheld laser devices.
NIST’s laser safety officer Joshua Hadler designed the measurement test bed (J. Hadler and M. Dowell, ‘Accurate, inexpensive testing of laser pointer power for safe operation’, Measurement Science and Technology; published online 7 March 2013). The system consists of a laser power meter and two optical filters to quantify the emissions of different wavelengths of visible and infrared light. The power meter and filters were calibrated at NIST. Lens holders ensure repeatable laser alignment, and an adjustable aperture contains the laser light around the output end of the laser.
“The measurement system is designed so that anyone can build it using off-the-shelf parts for about $2000,” says Hadler. “By relying on manufacturers’ traceability to a national measurement institute such as NIST, someone could use this design to accurately measure power from a laser pointer.”
